South Africa on Friday denied flouting international law in 2015 by failing to arrest visiting Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir, who is wanted for trial by war crimes judges on charges of genocide in Darfur.
At an unprecedented hearing at the International Criminal Court, Pretoria disputed accusations it had broken its obligations to the very tribunal it helped found.
There “was no duty under international law on South Africa to arrest the serving head of a non-state party such as Mr Omar al-Bashir,” Pretoria’s legal advisor Dire Tladi argued.
Despite two international arrest warrants issued in 2009 and 2010, Bashir remains at large and in office amid the raging conflict in the western Sudanese region of Darfur.
He has denied the ICC’s charges, including three accusations of genocide as well as war crimes and crimes against humanity.
The deadly conflict broke out in 2003 when ethnic minority groups took up arms against Bashir’s Arab-dominated government, which launched a brutal counter-insurgency.
The UN Security Council asked the ICC in 2005 to investigate the crimes in Darfur, where at least 300,000 people have been killed and 2.5 million displaced, according to UN figures.
‘No immunity waiver’
Pretoria, which had sought legal clarification from ICC judges before Bashir’s 2015 visit, argues that the Sudanese leader has immunity as a head of state.
There was “nothing at all” in the UN resolution that waived Bashir’s immunity, Tladi said.
Therefore Pretoria could not arrest him during his brief visit to South Africa in June 2015 for an African Union summit, despite its obligation to cooperate with the ICC as a signatory of the tribunal’s founding Rome Statute.
“The duty to arrest Mr Omar al-Bashir was not as clear as the office of the prosecutor would suggest,” Tladi said.
But prosecutor Julian Nicholls shot back that South Africa “had the ability to arrest and surrender him and it chose not to do so,” allowing Bashir and his delegation to fly home unimpeded from a military air base.
In the end the only reason Pretoria did not arrest him was “that South Africa disagreed with the court’s jurisprudence, the law as set out… so it did not comply.”
Several victims of the conflict, who now live in The Netherlands, attended the daylong hearing at the tribunal in The Hague.
“We know that Bashir will come to the ICC one day, if he’s alive,” Yousif Fasher, 30, told AFP.
“It will take time, five years, 10 years, two years, six years. But one day he has to come and stand in front of the ICC. That’s our message to South Africa.”
Presiding judge Cuno Tarfusser said the aim of the hearing was to decide “whether South Africa failed to comply with its obligations… by not arresting and surrendering Omar al-Bashir… while he was on South African territory.”
‘Most serious crimes’
The prosecution argues that since the ICC does not have its own police force it relies on member states to help execute arrest warrants.
Without such help, “the court’s going to be unable to carry out its most basic function: putting on trial persons charged with the most serious crimes,” Nicholls said.
Tarfusser said at the end of the hearing that he hoped the judges would return their decision before the court’s summer recess, and would do so in another public hearing.
The judges may decide to agree with the prosecution’s request to report Pretoria to the UN Security Council for non-compliance and eventual sanctions.
But Pretoria’s lawyers said such a move would be “unwarranted and unnecessary”, aimed only at casting South Africa “in a bad light”.
Although this is the first public hearing of its type, last year the ICC referred Chad, Djibouti and Uganda to the UN for also failing to arrest Bashir. So far no action has been taken against them.
The Sudanese leader was also a guest last month at an Arab League summit hosted by Jordan — also a signatory to the Rome Statute.
South Africa had moved to withdraw from the court, angered by the case against it.
But it formally revoked its decision last month after its own High Court ruled it would be unconstitutional.
Join GhanaStar.com to receive daily email alerts of breaking news in Ghana. GhanaStar.com is your source for all Ghana News. Get the latest Ghana news, breaking news, sports, politics, entertainment and more about Ghana, Africa and beyond.